Emilia Perez

IMDb: 5.9 – Decinemal Rating 7.0

---

Summary (created using Gemini AI)

Amelia Perez: A Controversial Film Review

• A review of the film Amelia Perez, directed by Jacques Audiard
• The film, in Spanish with music, is nominated for 13 Oscars.
• The reviewer notes both positive and negative aspects of the film.

Amelia Perez: A Divisive Film Review

• IMDb rating of Amelia Perez, available on Netflix since October, is below 6.0 after numerous votes.
• The film’s low rating suggests a significant level of negative feedback from viewers.
• The rating indicates a highly divisive reception, with strong opinions both for and against the movie.

A Film’s Remarkable Award Nominations

• The film received 13 Oscar nominations and 12 Bafta nominations.
• It also garnered 8 or 9 Golden Globe nominations, winning four.
• The sheer number of nominations raises questions about the film’s actual merit.

A Director’s Departure: From French Cinema to American Style

• The film’s issues originate with the director’s background in French cinema and philosophy.
• The director’s previous works include acclaimed films like ‘Rust and Bone’.

Mexican Transgender Musical Drama

• A Spanish-language film set in Mexico explores the downfall of masculine violence through the lens of a transgender character.
• The film incorporates songs and a fantastical approach to the serious subject of drug cartels.
• Criticism focuses on the film’s perceived pretentiousness, bizarre elements, and a French director’s portrayal of Mexican culture and cartels.

A Cinematic Exploration of Identity

• The film uses a transgender subject as a narrative device, not the central theme.
• The story focuses on individual choices rather than the transgender experience itself.
• The lead actress’s personal journey adds another layer to the film’s narrative.

A Transgender Drug Lord’s Transformation

• The story centers around four female characters, three of whom are particularly important.
• It features a transgender drug lord seeking to change their life.
• A lawyer is compelled to assist, and a young wife remains unaware of the situation.

A Fairytale Film’s Musical Journey

• The film is presented as a fairytale, not aiming for realism.
• The musical numbers are of varying quality, some well-integrated, others poorly placed.
• The film’s tone shifts inconsistently between serious, lighthearted, and comedic.

A Meandering Cinematic Journey

• The film’s cinematography is striking and well-executed.
• The narrative lacks a clear through-line, shifting unexpectedly between genres and tones.
• The pacing is uneven, with moments of beauty interspersed with boredom and jarring shifts in style.

Film Review: Stellar Performances Despite Narrative Flaws

• The film’s direction, writing, and editing lack clarity of purpose.
• Zoe Saldana delivers an outstanding supporting performance as lawyer Rita, deserving of accolades.
• Selena Gomez also gives a good performance, although her role is limited; one song in the film is a highlight.

A Stellar Performance and Catchy Tune

• Zoe’s performance is exceptional, excelling in singing, dancing, and acting.
• The film’s cinematography is also noteworthy and deserves recognition.
• The main theme song is catchy and contributes significantly to the film’s success.

Musical Score Analysis

• A musical score is considered for nomination despite its niche appeal.
• The overall work is deemed inconsistent, with some songs lacking context.
• Future reception and momentum of the score are anticipated with interest.

A Film’s Tonal Shift and Audience Reception

• The film’s bizarre and off-kilter tone is criticized, suggesting a potential for improvement by removing the musical elements.
• The film’s emotional impact is initially strong but diminishes in the second half due to the direction.
• The central characters’ believability suffers, resulting in a loss of audience sympathy and engagement.

A Film Review: Contrasting Initial Impression and Final Verdict

• An initial strong impression of a film fades as the viewing progresses.
• Despite its flaws, the film is considered a work of art, citing strong performance and cinematography.
• The film’s low IMDb rating is attributed to negative reactions outweighing positive ones.

A Controversial Film Review

• The Decinemal Rating assigns a 7.0 rating, classifying it as a borderline 4-star movie.
• The rating is influenced by both positive and negative reviews, with a lack of extreme high ratings.
• The film’s artistic merit is acknowledged, although it’s deemed undeserving of its numerous Oscar nominations.

A Critical Film Review: Oscars and a Waste of Time

• A lengthy critique of a film is presented.
• The film’s numerous Oscar nominations are deemed ironic, given the negative review.
• The reviewer encourages viewers to form their own opinions and watch the Oscars with interest.

---